West Virginia’s Premier Business Publication

Growth in West Virginia

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Tumblr
WhatsApp
Email

A Q&A with John Deskins

Compiled by Samantha Cart

John Deskins on street of Thomas, WV.
Photo by Tracy A. Toler Photography.

Media coverage and public discourse of the economy have intensified over the last decade. Post-pandemic financial realities, fluctuating inflation and fiscal pressures have changed how we discuss economic highs and lows.

Today, economic data points to slow but continual growth. Times when businesses are hiring and production is high are marked by the success of the nation’s fastest growing and most sustainable industries.

While West Virginia remains a leader in energy, the state continues its mission to diversify its economy from health care and information services to manufacturing and hospitality. John Deskins, Ph.D., director of the West Virginia University Bureau of Business and Economic Research, has been compiling data and advising leaders on the economy since 2013.

Deskins holds bachelor’s degrees in management and economics from Emory & Henry College and a Ph.D. in economics from the University of Tennessee. His expertise includes economic forecasting, economic development, small business economics and labor force participation.

In this Q&A with West Virginia Executive, Deskins discusses West Virginia’s growth opportunities, workforce, industry prospects and challenges.

How can West Virginia ensure counties struggling to gain economic traction can share in the state’s economic growth and success?

Many of our counties are trapped in a vicious cycle. The counties were not well diversified historically. Then a shock hits—typically a loss of coal jobs or steel jobs, for example, in the Northern Panhandle—and this causes people to move away to look for work. The out-migrants tend to be younger, healthier and better prepared for the workforce. This leaves the area more sparsely populated, older and less attractive to potential employers, thus making it even more difficult to diversify and spark momentum.

To break free from this vicious cycle, a county either needs to be adjacent to a growth county or it needs some outside-the-box positive shock. A handful of counties will probably benefit from proximity to our growth areas and start to grow as prosperity spreads out geographically. Otherwise, it is very difficult to experience a positive shock. It takes entrepreneurial leaders who know how to leverage an area’s competitive advantages. Mason County is probably one of the counties that will break free from the vicious cycle given the expansion of Nucor, a data center and a few other businesses.

How important is it to shift the state into looking at revenues that are more than safety nets, specifically transfer payments?

Given our aging and relatively unhealthy population, so many of our public resources are spent on transfer programs. That cannot be the full extent of government activity if we are to enjoy a healthy economy. The state must do more to invest in public goods and services that make our state more livable and attractive to potential in-migrants. We need stronger investment in public health, including more preventive measures, public education and quality-of-life amenities, such as investment in our state parks and other outdoor recreation amenities that make our state uniquely attractive and strong.

What is keeping people out of the labor force?

We have four big factors that are keeping people out of the workforce in West Virginia. The first is the fact that we have an older population. There is not much we can do about that in the short term, but it is important to remember we are at the bottom among states for even prime-working-age labor force participation, so it is not just about age.

The other big factors relate to human capital: First, poor education outcomes and a lack of workforce preparedness are keeping people out of the workforce. They know they do not have the skills or credentials required to get hired, so they are not looking for work in the first place. Second, poor health. Some folks would like to work, but they are not able to due to a health problem. West Virginia ranks somewhere between 45th and 50th among the states in terms of overall mortality, diabetes, obesity, cancer, lack of exercise and smoking. Third, drug use. Some West Virginians would like to work but are not able to because they have become addicted. West Virginia is an outlier in terms of drug overdose deaths. Not only do we have the highest drug overdose death rate, but we are above the second-highest state by a very wide margin.

One additional factor that is keeping people out of the workforce is a lack of affordable childcare. In many parts of West Virginia, childcare is so expensive that the math around having a second parent work does not really make sense. In many other parts of West Virginia, childcare is simply unavailable at any price.

How are you seeing quality-of-life investments play into economic development? How do we make West Virginia a place where people want to live?

Quality-of-life investments are becoming more important to economic development today. Traditionally, economic development has focused on bringing in one large business with a lot of jobs. Typically, a large manufacturing facility. There is still a role for this type of development strategy for sure, but there are fewer “attractable” jobs today, given the changing nature of our economy, especially with the dominance of service-oriented jobs and the decreasing importance of physical location.

Some new research has found that today much movement in the nation is driven by people moving to where they want to live because of various quality-of-life factors, and then the jobs follow the people. Essentially, the opposite dynamic that dominated the economy for years. You see this especially in attractive cities such as Austin, Denver and Charlotte.

The implication of this evolving trend is that West Virginia needs to invest in such a way that we become the place that people want to live in this part of the country. Investments can be especially rewarding when they improve the quality of life for West Virginians and bolster our tourism economy at the same time—investments in state parks, for example.

What would you consider the single biggest threat to West Virginia’s economy over the next decade?

I think the biggest threat we face is with our fundamental demographics. The fact that so many of our counties are sparsely populated with large proportions of older folks, far fewer younger people, low labor force participation and few kids, is the biggest challenge we face. The problem is that there is not much we can do to fight this directly, and the challenge will probably not be overcome for some of our counties, even within the next decade or more.

Should West Virginia focus less on job announcements and more on data points like labor force participation, household income growth, population growth and educational success?

We should focus on all of the above. I try to educate people on all these aspects of the economy in my work. Also, job announcements are great, and I applaud policymakers and economic development leaders when businesses and jobs are
attracted to our state. These announcements can be a little misleading. I mean, suppose we announce 500 new jobs in a county, but a year later the total number of jobs in the state is flat. The issue is that the 500 new jobs receive a lot of attention, but small job losses of five or 10 jobs here or there get very little attention. To understand the economy, people have to take a more holistic approach to understand the entire jobs dynamic and not just read the headlines about good economic development events that are touted.

A big problem here is that a specific jobs announcement is a discrete event that is easily reportable, but generally, gains with factors like human capital, education, etcetera, occur slowly over a long period of time and thus are not as easy for reporters to cover.

What potential do you think data centers will have for West Virginia’s economy? What policies should the state be focusing on to ensure the best economic outcomes?

I think data centers can be positive for West Virginia. They create some jobs directly, and they support many more jobs through indirect effects. Perhaps most importantly, they can generate significant property tax revenue. The data centers are happening and they are going somewhere, so why not bring them to West Virginia rather than our competitor states?

That said, policymakers should absolutely ensure that we take the right steps to curb any negative side effects associated with data centers. If I were in a position of authority, I would hold hearings with non-partisan experts to learn about any potential noise, air or water pollution that data centers will likely create and ensure balanced policies are enacted to prevent these negative side effects while still allowing West Virginia to enjoy the economic boost that data centers can bring.

From your research, what evidence-based policies would move the needle toward economic growth the fastest?

I do not believe we are going to be able to generate widespread, statewide growth very rapidly. The policies I think will work for West Virginia are generally long-term investments that will not yield results in just a year or two. We can work to sell West Virginia to various businesses such as Nucor, and those wins can make big differences in some regions in the short term. But statewide, we need broad investment in public health and education and improved quality of life, and we need to ensure we do not have undue or antiquated regulations or other policies that make West Virginia unattractive to people and businesses.

Can you explain population loss versus immigration and how these factors are impacting West Virginia’s economy?

West Virginia’s population decline over the last decade is driven by natural population loss. This is when the state experiences more deaths than births. Over the past 10 years or so, West Virginia has seen about 7,000 more deaths than births annually. This pattern is fundamentally driven by an older population.

The other part of population change is net migration. The fact is that the net migration figure has been positive in our state for five years now. Last year, over 6,000 more people moved to West Virginia than the number who moved out. The figure was not quite enough to offset the natural population loss, but this is very encouraging, nonetheless. Hopefully we can get the net-migration figure up to 10,000 or 20,000 in coming years.

As a native of Virginia, what keeps you motivated to continue working in and contributing to West Virginia?

I am from Southwestern Virginia, very close to the West Virginia border. As such, my home is far more similar to Southern West Virginia than most of Virginia. I consider myself an Appalachian and son of the Virginias, and as such, I feel at home in West Virginia.

Ultimately, I am driven by a love of this place and its complex and wonderful history. I want to see the area and its people thrive and move beyond always being near the bottom of the prosperity rankings. I want us to become a gem in the eastern U.S.—a place filled with natural beauty, cool towns and small cities and a destination to retreat away from the crowded Eastern Seaboard.

Economic Industry Outliers

Mining, health care, information services and professional services are among the fastest-growing sectors in the state. What’s driving growth in those industries, and why are so many other sectors struggling to keep pace?

Mining is growing because of gas output. It continues to grow rapidly after more than a decade of growth. Health care is booming as well, largely because of our demographics: aging and poor health. Information and professional services are driven by national growth in those sectors.

Professional, scientific and technical services have grown almost 40% over the past decade and is expected to continue growing. What opportunities does this create for attracting and retaining young professionals?

This is a growing sector nationally and in West Virginia with many attractive job opportunities. Young people should look in this sector for jobs and gear their education path accordingly. We must continue to produce more young college graduates with not only the right skills but also a desire to stay in West Virginia to support continued growth.

Manufacturing growth was relatively modest from 2015 to 2025 but is projected to accelerate through 2030. What factors are contributing to that optimism?

On the durables side, manufacturing posted strong growth, and that is really expected to continue. The slow growth over the past decade was only on the nondurables side. On the durables side, we have had some important gains, and that is expected to continue. Companies like FORM and Nucor will be boosting durables manufacturing moving forward.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *