By Maggie Blankenship
Wheeling, WV’s, culinary scene is a direct reflection of its unique spirit. From long-standing restaurants that have been operating for generations to new, contemporary spots that offer modern experiences, the city hosts an array of diverse dining options. Whether visitors prefer comfort food, a more elegant atmosphere or a laid-back coffee run, there is something in Wheeling to accommodate.
While exploring Wheeling’s food landscape, it becomes clear that each dish from its restaurants, thoughtfully crafted using local, fresh ingredients, is created with passion and creativity. Menus offer both timeless favorites and modern creations, and these spots offer more than just a meal—they offer guests a chance to connect with the community and enjoy a fun experience. For visitors and locals alike, each of these Wheeling spots offer something different for all to enjoy.
Coleman’s Fish Market
Coleman’s Fish Market, located in Wheeling’s Historic Centre Market district, has been serving fresh seafood for a century. Started by John Coleman in 1914, the family-owned business has been a beloved destination for seafood-loving locals. John’s son, Joe, took over when he passed away and has now owned the restaurant for 51 years. The market is known for its signature hand-fileted fish sandwich—fried fish between two slices of white bread—which is a favorite for many across the state and beyond. Along with this popular menu item, Coleman’s offers a variety of quality seafood, including crab, lobster and squid.The restaurant also offers a variety of soups, the most popular being its clam chowder and lobster bisque.
Coleman’s also serves a variety of sides like macaroni and cheese and pork egg rolls as well as three types of fries: French fries pub style, seasoned fries and Route 66 potato wedges. With options like these, there is no doubt customers will find the perfect addition to their fish sandwich, making for a fresh, tasty and locally made meal.
The market’s long-standing tradition of quality and freshness has made it a staple in the community. Generations of families have come to Coleman’s, not just for the food but for the friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit special. Whether a longtime local or a visitor passing through, Coleman’s Fish Market offers a unique and delicious experience that keeps people coming back year after year.
Sarah’s on Main
Sarah’s on Main is a stylish bakery, brunch and coffee shop on Wheeling’s Main Street. This local destination is known for its tasty homemade treats, which include muffins, yogurt, cakes and cookies. Whether customers are in the mood for sweet or savory, Sarah’s has something fitting on the menu. The shop also offers sandwiches, soups and salads as well as its signature salty bread, which is a favorite for many of the restaurant’s regulars. For coffee lovers, Sarah’s offers varieties of cold brew coffee, hot coffee and lattes, making it the perfect place to start your day or enjoy a relaxing afternoon.
In addition to the regular menu, Sarah’s has a unique selection of weekly specials, giving customers fun new dishes to try each time they visit. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic dish or want to try something new, there are always plenty of options. The cozy and welcoming atmosphere at Sarah’s makes it an ideal spot for breakfast, brunch or a relaxing coffee break. With each visit offering a delightful experience, Sarah’s has quickly become a go-to destination in the Wheeling community, perfect for any occasion.
Trace Chophouse
Trace Chophouse, located at Oglebay, offers a unique dining experience that celebrates Wheeling’s history. The restaurant is inspired by the trailblazers who traveled west along National Road, and the dining room hearth features walnut logs from the original Zane Log Cabin, the first building in Wheeling, built in 1769.
The menu at Trace Chophouse includes steaks, imported cuts and house-aged specialties. It offers premium cuts of beef, including the famous A5 Wagyu, known as the highest grade of beef in the world. Seafood lovers can enjoy fresh options like scallops, trout, tuna and lobster as well as a full raw bar. The restaurant also features more than 150 options of wines, spirits and smoked cocktails, guided by an in-house sommelier.
Trace Chophouse stands out for its blend of history and modern dining. From the meticulously chosen décor to the friendly service, everything is designed to create an unforgettable experience. Whether you’re a history buff or just looking for a great meal, Trace Chophouse has something to offer.
Later Alligator
One of Wheeling’s most unforgettable eats is Later Alligator, a quaint destination on Wheeling’s Market Street. The restaurant’s specialty lies in its delectable crepes, but the menu is packed with plenty of other distinctive items that attract many daily visitors. Later Alligator is stacked with drink options, including a full espresso bar that offers every kind of latte a coffee lover could imagine. Also on the menu are wraps, salads, sides and a list of more than 20 sandwich options. Customers can choose from the restaurant’s list of beers, wines, martinis and cocktails, making Later Alligator the perfect place to stop for a handcrafted drink.
Later Alligator is full of fun activities that add to its dining experience. The restaurant hosts the Critical Critter Society book club, which meets at the location on the last Wednesday of each month to discuss the latest read. It also puts on regular trivia nights with varying themes such as art history and mythology. In the outdoor courtyard, Later Alligator often provides live music to patrons, sometimes accompanied by a warm fire. With its large menu and plethora of fun-filled experiences to enjoy, this location is certainly a popular one.
Elle & Jack’s
Elle & Jack’s is a newer spot in Wheeling’s downtown area. The restaurant’s goal is to foster a warm and welcoming atmosphere open to all guests while providing high-quality, elevated meals. The restaurant has separate lunch and dinner menus, both of which feature classic favorites and unique restaurant-only specialties. Elle & Jack’s offers classic American cuisine with a creative twist, which includes a variety of dishes made from locally sourced ingredients. Customers can grab sandwiches, salads or burgers for lunch or wait until dinnertime and enjoy a fresh salad, savory appetizer or fine, handcrafted entrée. From steaks and seafood to creative vegetarian options, the menu caters to a wide range of palates.
The restaurant has quickly become a favorite among locals since its opening in 2021. The dining room combines elegance and rustic charm, featuring warm lighting, stylish décor and a cozy ambiance that makes every dining experience special. Elle & Jack’s values its customer service and works hard to ensure that every guest feels welcome and well cared for. Whether customers are looking for a romantic dinner, family gathering or a night out with friends, Elle & Jack’s offers the right food and experience, served in the perfect setting.
